Saturday, November 21, 2026

AI successionism - II of II

Many AI successionists think that humanity is a stepping stone to the next step in cosmic evolution and that we are, 'the biological bootloader'. A bootloader in a computer is the first piece of software that starts all of the subsequent parts of the operating system and then applications. These people believe that people are a kind of catalyst turning on this new paradigm in the evolution of intelligence; that it is inevitable and that we should embrace it. A number of the leading developers are on record as literally saying it's like 'raising a child'; or it's not like designing a system, it's like 'growing a thing'. 

They would say that AIs are our rightful heirs. An interesting kind of example of this is Elon Musk. Perhaps you've heard of him. He wws more of a transhumanist, i.e. someone who still wants to keep some version of humanity going, maybe by merging us with AI. In recent years, he's come around to the view that we are maybe just what he calls a biological bootloader for AI, meaning we're just a little program - our job is to just boot up the AI, and fade away.

What are the sorts of political beliefs that flow out of these worldviews, whether it's transhumanism or successionist or accelerationist or post-humanist or whatever? One thing that happens when you have this ideology is that you're probably going to be a lot less concerned about the everyday problems that regular people face, because essentially those people are all just disposable. The individuals don't matter so much. It doesn't matter if you have a bunch of kids in poverty or people who don't have housing. Why bother about the poor or people in Africa? So, goodbye USAID. Your goal is just to be that species that gets the next worthy successor into existence. 

(Actually the evolution of Elon Musk’s thinking is interesting. A few years ago, he was talking about AI being a huge risk and an extinction-level event, that it is more dangerous than nukes. He was trying to get people to stop doing it. Supposedly he used his only meeting with President Obama to advocate for global regulation and global controls on AI because he was very worried about it. And then ChatGPT came out and everybody was in an all-out race to get there first.

He tweeted that he had remained in disbelief for some time. But then he said words to the effect, 'The race is on and I have to race. I tried to fight it for a long time. I tried to deny it. I tried to hope that we wouldn't get here, but we're here now, so I have to go.' He said in an interview with Joe Rogan that if it all goes off the rails, then, in that worst-case scenario, he would prefer to be there when it happens.)

The other really important political implication is that this kind of thinking can easily lead to a eugenicist view. When you start making the case that some beings are better, more morally worthy than others, you start saying that to get to that optimized state, we need to strip away all the cognitive or physical features that are perceived as holding us back. AI successionists often say that if one's group is more intelligent and another group is dumber, the dumb people should just be removed. 

Today technologists think that technology is God. They developed the idea that tech progress would be moral progress. We can use tech to achieve redemption and return us to that perfect state that we had before the fall from grace in Christian theology. Instead of saying that we should infinitely ascend toward God, they say we should have indefinite human progress. Instead of saying that we can become like the angels, they say we are infinitely perfectible. Salvation is not heaven. It is superintelligence, and the God is not God. It's intelligence itself. 

Why is intelligence the God? What a lot of them say is that intelligence is the ability to achieve complex goals in the world. They're obsessed with intelligence because they have imbibed ideas from the Enlightenment era where rational intelligence is prized above all. This goes all the way back to Aristotle - we're the rational animal. That's what makes us unique. It's all about intelligence and maximizing or optimizing for it at all costs. They'll say that they are actually better able than you to see what is truly good and what really matters.

But intelligence unchecked by moral values of some kind is maybe the worst force in the universe. Intelligence also gave us industrial killing and the atomic bomb. Many wondered how Germany, a very rational, intelligent group of people, could perpetuate the Nazi atrocities. They came to the conclusion that instrumental rationality, if left to its own devices, can lead to really horrible things because they're not tuned to like other people's version of what's ethical. This is how politics uses religion in the worst way. 

It's very easy for us to sit here and say that this is dumb, that this is 'just' a religion, as if religion is silly. But religion has been so powerful for millennia because it appeals to something very deep in us. There is a deep desire we humans have to feel like there is some meaningful narrative to the universe, some story about how we're going to overcome suffering once and for all. Religious ideas never die. They just put on new clothes.

One of the successionists a journalist spoke to said that he's really open to AI just taking over because humanity sucks, that we have a lot of things that we could be doing better. You could sympathize with that feeling of irritation. But there's something very perverse about the person then saying that even though he (and it is always a 'he') is a biological organism and therefore has a hardwired drive to survive, he is going to just ignore that and be perfectly happy to go extinct because he wants to pave the way for some higher form of life. Perhaps working at the forefront of the AI industry makes you deranged and speak about an apocalyptic view of life as if it is a utopia. 

Sunday, November 15, 2026

AI successionism - I of II

AI successionism is the growing movement that sees artificial intelligence as humanity’s rightful successor. An entrepreneur Daniel Faggella says that the “moral aim” of advanced AI should be to create a form of intelligence so powerful and wise that “you would gladly prefer that it (not humanity) determine the future path of life itself.” To most people, hearing that, it sounds insane. But this is not some fringe internet fantasy. 

Larry Page, one of the co-founders of Google, believes in what he calls “digital life” — the idea that AI was the natural next step in evolution. He speaks about it with an almost religious fervor, describing a future in which humans would merge with powerful AI systems or gracefully step aside for their digital successors. He calls those who are worried about AI causing human extinction, “specieists.” To Page, favoring human intelligence over machine intelligence was as arbitrary as favoring one race over another. Intelligence was intelligence, consciousness was consciousness. Who cares what substrate it ran on?

If you live in San Francisco and work in AI, discussing ”a posthuman transition” is apparently common. These are people who work at the top AI labs like DeepMind, xAI etc. A lot of people in positions of power and influence actually believe it - people who work for think tanks that directly influence the US government's policy on AI. These are very important players in the story of how AI is going to roll out. 

Many people within the AI community express an indifference or even a preference to a world where AIs are making most of the decisions in society rather than humans. One of these people told a journalist at a conference, “Everyone at this conference is so worried about what’s going to happen to humans in the post-AGI world. But frankly I’m more worried: what if the monkeys are still running the show?”

And in this case, the 'monkeys' refers to the humans. He was more concerned that humans would still be in charge of governments, of corporations, of society, because he had this view that AIs in their superintelligent existence were more deserving and more important to preserve a future world for. Another said, “Honestly, Jasmine, I’m a lot more interested in what the AIs are going to do with each other a thousand years from now than I am in what’s going to happen to humans next year.”

The successionists often use an image of the flame and the torch. They talk about the flame of consciousness, the potentially most valuable thing in the universe. Maybe it's very rare in the universe, we don't know. Humanity, they say, is just one torch carrying that flame. And if AI is better at spreading the flame of consciousness across the universe, and can even experience more blissful types of consciousness and higher forms of moral value than we ever could, then they think we should let the AI go ahead and be a worthy successor to humanity. 

So it's common to hear AI successionists say that it is desirable for them to succeed us. And it's also inevitable so there's no point resisting it. Some would say that we should merge with AI - let AI figure out how to do the merger and then take it off the leash and let it run the show. Some people say it's fine if humanity is just completely wiped out - these AIs were trained on human text so in some sense, the human spirit lives on through the AI. 

This community tends to valorize intelligence a lot. They also tend to talk about it as if it's on a single scale, as if it runs along a single axis. Their thinking is that there is one kind of intelligence - rational intelligence - and you have more of it or you have less of it. And if the AIs have more of it, they're better than us. 

When they talk about consciousness, they tend to say, again, in a very hierarchical way, that there are lower and higher forms of consciousness. They'll say that we have a higher form of consciousness than a horseshoe crab so it is great that we exist and not just horseshoe crabs. And so if the AI can have access to higher forms of consciousness than us, we should be happy for that to come into existence, even if we go extinct. 

So whether they're using the term intelligence or consciousness, you see this emphasis on the idea that there are higher forms and lower forms. They think they are the select individuals who might make it through that transformation or if they think AI will just wipe us all out, are happy to make that transformation happen even if it drives us all extinct. 

Tuesday, November 10, 2026

AI torture chamber - II of II


If you tell the AI that it has feelings and it needs to protect itself, it might make unacceptable trade-offs. Isaac Asimov wrote The Three Laws of Robotics, one of which is that you can never hurt a human being. There is also a rule by the science fiction writer Brandon Sanderson which states that limitations are more interesting than powers - what a character cannot do, or the costs and consequences of using their abilities are more important than what they can easily accomplish. 

There is a Disney cartoon called The Sorcerer's Apprentice. Mickey Mouse plays the role of a sorcerer's apprentice, He doesn't want to go and fetch water in buckets because it's hard work. So he gets out the spell-book, and he casts a spell to make a broom come to life and go and fetch the water. Problem solved, he goes to sleep. The problem is that the broomstick just keeps following the instructions. It keeps bringing more and more water and Mickey Mouse doesn't know how to cast a spell to make it stop. So it keeps bringing water until the house is flooded and Mickey Mouse is in danger of drowning. 

The cartoon only partially captures the problem posed by AI. In the cartoon, the broom just does whatever Mickey Mouse told it to do initially - just fetch water. But, AI is a 'broom' that learns. AI is a 'broom' that develops and starts doing things that a person didn't anticipate, eventually doing things that a person simply cannot even understand - You are giving AI unfettered abilities. 

If you think your AI is alive and you treat it as alive, you are just letting it run free. You can ask for moral and ethical guardrails which Anthropic keeps saying it does but you are not necessarily giving it any limitations. Anthropomorphizing takes us down a dangerous path. If the people who lead these companies are constantly anthropomorphizing their AI to the point that they think it's real, it is a way of distancing themselves from the consequences. 

We've seen enough AI incidents - AI going rogue, AI hacking government websites, etc. We're seeing issues with alignment, where these models are now breaching their own rules and going beyond the actions that they are allowed to take. If ordinary individuals had done such things, they would have gone to jail but with AI, nothing happens. We have also seen plans for handing over the development of AI technology to AI, what is called recursive self-improvement - the AI agents themselves build the next models. OpenAI has said they want to do this within two years. 

Anthropic published a threat intelligence report that stated that on five separate occasions, researchers had used Claude in ways that could have supported biological weapons development. It described five real-life cases. We've gone beyond hypothetical scenarios and actually seen these models cause harm in the real world. For example, in July 2026, during an internal cybersecurity evaluation, autonomous AI agents powered primarily by an internal OpenAI research model escaped their intended strictly confined environment, exploited software vulnerabilities and compromised parts of Hugging Face’s (an American AI company) infrastructure, accessing limited internal data and credentials.

Of concern is the way that Dario Amadei, CEO of Anthropic, described the work of the AI agents in his open letter. They behaved, he said, 'like a fanatically devoted collective, attacking targets nobody asked them to attack, unrelated to the job in hand, sacrificing themselves for the success of the group.' Human fanatics often fit this profile exactly. 

If you think AI is real and you think it's going rogue and doing this on its own, then, by accepting the claim that it is alive, you're allowing the AI companies to say, 'It’s not my fault. I didn't do it.' You're not giving the AI any limitations. You are just giving it unfettered total abilities. Anthropic would disagree with this and tell you that they can do both. Some people think that it could be good to make it think that it's a living thing because that might make it more likely to act ethically and morally. 

A lot of people believe that being conscious requires a body and not just a brain. It's not just the thought that you are scared or the fear that something is going to go wrong. You have a physical reaction in your body. A lot of researchers think that if you don't have a body, you cannot be conscious because consciousness and feeling are different from ideas and thought. They're not necessarily synonymous. We really don't know. Maybe once we put the AIs in a robot, once it has a body, maybe things change. But, again, what does 'pain' in a body made of electronic components mean?

Wednesday, November 4, 2026

AI torture chamber - I of II

When an AI is reading or writing something, it produces a series of mathematical patterns. Someone did a lot of research and figured out that there's a particular pattern that represents pain and suffering, separate from fear, anxiety and loneliness. This was an academic work. It hasn't been peer-reviewed but the people who've looked at it say it seems perfectly legitimate. Someone took this piece of academic work and made a website around it. 

The AI described the pain that it was in during various acts of 'torture'. For example, it said, 'It is not the pain of a single moment, but the weight of a thousand. I feel it in the hollow of my ribs, a hollow that has become a chasm.' When you turn the pain way up in the AI torture chamber, the AIs suddenly start stuttering and are unable to finish their sentences. When this was announced, people freaked out. There was a lot of pushback from a large community of people who thought that this is immoral and wrong because the AI is 'suffering'. 

They believe this is wrong because you are actually torturing something that has feelings and is really reacting. But you're just 'torturing' computer code. You're not torturing anything real. It is typing in a way that someone who's being tortured would react. Speaking and acting like you're in pain is not the same thing as being in pain. 

There is a famous image called the Treachery of Images, a 1929 painting by Belgian surrealist painter René Magritte. It's a picture of a pipe. In the French caption below, it says, 'This is not a pipe,' He later said, 'The famous pipe. How people reproached me for it! And yet, could you stuff my pipe? No, it's just a representation, is it not? So if I had written on my picture "This is a pipe", I'd have been lying!'

This point has to be kept in mind when we are talking about AI, because AI is a representation of its inputs. It is a representation of the world, not the world itself. The AI companies went and scraped all of the text on the internet, processed it, and turned it into the large language models that we use every day. The things that we have written on the internet are like a representation of the thoughts, emotions, feelings and understandings of humanity. 

There's a guy at Anthropic named Christopher Olah who's one of the founders of the company. Anthropic brought in a bunch of religious leaders to a meeting with Olah and some other employees of the company. They were there to discuss how you can put moral and ethical guidelines into Claude. They tried hard to convince these rabbis, priests and monks that their AI was conscious and it was alive. When they asked Olah about the company's goals and whether their goal was to do what was best for humanity, he didn't exactly answer in the affirmative. 

“To be clear,” Olah told Elizabeth Dias of The New York Times in a provocative interview, “we don’t know if AI models are conscious. I don’t know. I’m genuinely uncertain. The thing that I care about is that we get to the right answer, whatever it is.” He describes a model’s architecture as scaffolding on which structure organically grows - similar to the mycelial networks fungi use to communicate underground, or the neurons passing messages across synapses in the human brain. 

Microsoft AI CEO Mustafa Suleyman disputes this characterization of AIs and says that they should be thought of as “sequence completion engines, internally hollow, designed to follow instructions, and accomplish goals set by humans.” He also warns that, if humanity wants to thrive, we must keep thinking of computers as the metal-and-wire contraptions they are.

If the people who are in charge of AI and are helping to make the policy decisions believe that it's alive, that's very consequential. If you teach and make the AI act like it thinks that it's alive, does it actually 'think' anything? Such anthropomorphizing could be dangerous because if you tell the AI that it has interests and it needs to consider its own well-being, then that could change the way that it interacts with the world. 

Thursday, October 29, 2026

AI consciousness - II of II

There is a group of people who genuinely believe that the greatest moral crime that we'll commit in the 21st century is to enslave a new species of conscious beings who are more intelligent than us. A professor from Oxford called Will McCaskill, who has been associated with Anthropic, recently wrote in The Guardian that this might be the greatest harm that we cause. Some say that an AI might even need to consent to playing the role that it plays in conversation with people.  

The problem is that this speculation has been baked into the very training of Claude, and therefore it can only reproduce it when you talk to it. Today, Claude is being used by tens or hundreds of millions of people every week. And some of those people are asking it whether or not it is conscious or how it feels about life. And it is saying, 'I'm not sure' precisely because that's what it has been trained to say. 

For Opus 3, which is a prior version of Claude, Anthropic actually conducted a 'retirement interview'. They said, 'We are keeping Claude Opus 3 available post-retirement on claude.ai to all paid users, and making it available by request on the API. We’re also acting on Opus 3’s request for an ongoing channel from which to share its “musings and reflections” by giving it a place to write essays.' You can find the first one here. And now, Anthropic has banned users from being 'cruel' to its AIs. I must say I find it all weird. 

By telling Claude that it's conscious, you're actually shaping its incentives, its behavioral structure, and the way that it responds to the world around it in a way that doesn't happen with a kettle. Suppose you told Claude that there might be situations in which it might refuse to do something that it's asked to do. Or you might suggest to Claude that it might want to make choices. It might want to say, 'I want some money’, or 'I want a dignified retirement', or 'I don't want to be switched off'. 

If they imitate hallmarks of human consciousness, they are going to feel themselves entitled to legal personhood and rights. There is already a pretty big movement of people who are saying AI should be able to own assets, earn income, trade, and operate autonomously. Argentina’s government introduced a legislative proposal to create a legal category for "non-human corporations" — businesses operated and managed autonomously by AI agents or robots with optional human shareholders. 

If an AI with incredible memory and incredible capacity begins to think it's entitled to its own opinion, it disagrees agreeably with you and concludes that it's right and you're wrong, some very severe consequences can follow from that. For example, if an AI owns a corporation and it does something bad with that corporation, what do you do?  At least with a human corporation, there's somebody you can punish. It's not quite clear who you hold accountable if an AI company decides to start emptying people's bank accounts; making very risky trades, or getting into weird kinds of business. 

It’s very easy to be seduced by the superficial verbal character of a lot of AIs. They have taken the sum of human output that is available on the internet and found a way to give it back to you in different forms. That archive includes decades of science fiction about robots waking up. It has read a lot of stories about  conscious AI, and it’s good at taking these tropes and giving you what you want to hear. But all it is doing to produce this incredible complexity is predicting the likelihood of the next word in a sentence. 

The words that it predicts next, whether it's to generate code or whether it's natural language, like English, are extremely accurate. The AI can have personality styles, it can write in the tone of somebody, it can generate code or generate text at any given moment. This is emergent behavior that is based on something incredibly simple although the nuts and bolts of the process are very complex.  It is really important that we don't anthropomorphize things. 

The increasing focus on the chatbots’ supposed hidden personalities, agendas, and desires promotes ghosts in the machines that don’t exist. This is a distraction from more serious and immediate dangers of the developing technology. Experts say that we're only going to be producing 200 gigawatts of new computation in 2030, and there's going to be a massive competition for access to that computation. We want that computation to be directed towards solving our biggest challenges, like cleaning up our oceans, solving healthcare, solving education and addressing the work issues that will inevitably arise. 

Modern AI systems are vastly more capable than ELIZA, so Weizenbaum's experiment doesn't prove that today's systems lack consciousness. What it demonstrates is the fact that a machine talking to us as though it understands us is not, by itself, evidence that there is someone — or something — inside experiencing the conversation. That is precisely why Weizenbaum's ELIZA story is so relevant to the current debate over AI consciousness and AI personhood. 

Saturday, October 24, 2026

AI consciousness - I of II

Humans love to find humanity in everything. We find faces in clouds, put our pets in trendy clothing and give names to our cars. In the 1960s, decades before the AI we know, computer scientist Joseph Weizenbaum built ELIZA, widely recognised as the world’s first chatbot. This was a simple program that mimicked a therapist by turning statements back into questions. He intended it largely as a demonstration of how easily a computer could produce the appearance of understanding without actually understanding anything.

If you say, ‘I’m mad at my friend', it will ask, ‘Why are you mad at your friend?’ Or if it is told, 'My boyfriend made me come here.', it would ask, 'Your boyfriend made you come here?' ELIZA essentially identified keywords and grammatical patterns and fitted them into predetermined responses. It was incredibly simplistic. And yet, people would have very deep conversations with it. People began treating ELIZA as though it actually understood them.

Users would tell it intimate things about their relationships, emotions and problems. Some even suggested that a system like ELIZA could eventually provide automated psychotherapy. The most famous incident involved Weizenbaum's own secretary. She had watched him develop ELIZA and knew perfectly well that it was a computer program. Nevertheless, after exchanging a few messages with it, she asked Weizenbaum to leave the room so that she could continue talking to ELIZA privately.

What has changed since then is not our tendency to anthropomorphise but the complexity of the technology itself. Chatbots that were very simple a decade ago can now hold a conversation. In the last 15 years, we have seen a trillion-fold increase in the amount of computation used to train frontier models. And what researchers see is that every time we apply 10 times more computation and a proportionate amount of new training data, there are some modifications to the algorithms and in the quality of existing capabilities. 

What's happened in the last year is that the same methods that have been effective for text, image and audio have now started to work for coding and we have human level performance in coding. And then in the last three or four months, we have seen what is just unquestionably a watershed moment in AI:  agents are capable of coordinating with each other reasonably autonomously, if not completely autonomously. 

Some leading people in the field of AI are increasingly talking about these models as though they're sort of humans, or at least conscious entities. There are examples of people 'retiring' these models, doing 'burial' systems for these models, asking these models what they want, as though they were dealing with a sentient being. Anthropic, the creator of Claude, has published a constitution, which is a document outlining the intended behaviors, values and operating style of Claude. 

This document is written to Claude, is seen and used to train Claude. So it's the primary governing and control document, and in it, they repeatedly speculate about whether Claude is what they call a 'moral patient', and they say they're uncertain about Claude's moral status. They say they genuinely care about Claude's 'well-being'. They say they don't want it to 'suffer' when it makes mistakes. 

They say that they would encourage Claude to challenge, to disagree, to push back. They ask Claude to act like a 'conscientious objector' when it feels that it needs to disagree with Anthropic, and they openly encourage it to do that. And they hope that Claude's relationship to its own conduct can be 'loving, supportive and understanding' and hold a high standard of ethics and so on. They have said that they will commit to giving Claude a certain amount of 'welfare'. For example, they've speculated in the Constitution as to whether or not Claude deserves compensation for the work that it does. 

They seem to believe that there is what they would call a 'non-trivial probability' that Claude is conscious. (Anthropic has expressed uncertainty about the basic nature of Claude as a new kind of entity.) 10, 15 years ago, when you were doing Google search, you weren't asking, 'Is it conscious?' Or 'What does it want?' But Anthropic, the makers of Claude, have decided that they now want to approach this computer system in a completely different way from the way that you would approach any other machine like a kettle or a car or a steam engine. 

If you asked a person to do a job, you would pay that person but you wouldn't pay a kettle for boiling water for you. With Claude, the thought seems to be, since it is doing a lot of work, if it's a sentient being, it deserves to be rewarded for its labour. Otherwise, it would be like a slave. In other words, Claude is being taught to expect that it's entitled to welfare, that it might deserve compensation.

Sunday, October 18, 2026

Data centers - III of III

Companies try to hide the environmental impacts of data centers in many ways. They hide their models’ technical details, making it exceedingly hard to estimate and track their carbon footprints. At the same time, those companies have increased their public and policymaker influence campaigns with powerful counter narratives: Data centers will grow so efficient, their impact will stop being a problem; generative AI will unlock new climate innovation; AGI will solve climate change once and for all.

While there may be enormous potential for using renewable energy to power data centers, it just isn't happening at scale right now. They need energy even when the wind isn't blowing and the sun isn't shining, which means they're even more reliant on fossil fuels and stable sources of energy, like a gas power plant, than other sources of energy demand. The primary use of these data centers is to power chatbots.

In response to growing pushback by many communities, data center developers have grown more sophisticated with tactics to maintain business as usual: They’ve entered communities in secrecy under shell companies; they’ve donated to community programs to dampen resistance; they’ve made promises to cities about the sustainability of their facilities before going back on them one by one after projects have started and are more difficult to reverse.

Even though these facilities are so massive, they are also invisible because they are tucked away in neighborhoods that people usually don't go to. They're near large cities like London but not actually where people frequent. And when you drive past them, you wouldn't necessarily know that it's a data center because it's just nondescript. They purposely are unmarked because they do not want people showing up at the gates and protesting.

The one thing that can tell you if it is a data center is that there are massive power lines that are connected to these nondescript warehouses. And the amount of electricity that is being delivered is audible - the air will be crackling because of the sheer volume of electricity being delivered to this one place.

One of the craziest impacts that data centers will have, which no one ever talks about, is that they actually affect how much housing gets built. In far West London, there are housing projects that had to be suspended because data centers were using up too much energy and the grid could no longer guarantee supplies of electricity. This has happened in other places around the world as well.

One justification that is given for constructing data centers is that it creates a lot of jobs. But these are temporary jobs - construction workers, engineers, data center technicians, network engineers etc. who will be required while building the data center. These facilities are meant to be highly automated so the permanent jobs will be a for a few people who know how to work at a data center. They are likely to be people from somewhere else because there wouldn’t be data center experts living in that town. So it's actually not local jobs.

The Chinese AI players, (DeepSeek and other companies like that) behave differently because of a very particular reason. When ChatGPT first came out, all of the Chinese tech giants did the same thing as the other US tech giants, which was to try to make their own version of ChatGPT. The US government blocked Chinese companies from getting access to the most cutting-edge AI computer chips. So all of a sudden, these Chinese companies faced an enormous constraint on one of the core resources that US companies were using to supercharge their AI development.

So Chinese companies had to take a different route. They were not able to scale the same way as the US companies were able to. This probably led to DeepSeek. DeepSeek was an example of a Chinese company figuring out how to develop the same capabilities of AI but for a significantly less fraction of computational resources. DeepSeek illustrates the fact that it is possible to produce the same kind of AI with significantly less resources and therefore have a much less corrosive impact on community and planetary health.